How can we reconcile between the fact that doctors can find out whether the foetus is male or female, and the aayah (interpretation of the meaning): “and [He] knows that which is in the wombs” [Luqmaan 31:24], and what was narrated in Tafseer Ibn Jareer from Mujaahid, that a man asked the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) what his wife would give birth to, and Allaah revealed this aayah, and what was narrated from Qutaadah (may Allaah have mercy on him)? Is there any aayah or hadeeth to make the general meaning of this aayah (“what is in the wombs”) more specific?
Praise be to Allaah.
Before I discuss this matter, I would like to explain
that there can never be any contradiction between an unambiguous statement
of the Qur’aan and reality. If there appears to be a contradiction with
reality, it is either because what we think is reality is a baseless
claim, or the (text of) the Qur’aan is not opposed to this reality
in a clear and definite manner. The unambiguous statements of the Qur’aan
and the facts of reality are both definitive, and two definitive things
can never contradict one another.
Based on the above, it may be said that now they (doctors)
are able, through the use of precise machines, to discover what is in
the wombs and to find out whether it is male or female. If what is said
is false, then there is no point in discussing it. If it is true, then
it does not contradict the aayah, because the aayah is referring to
a matter of the unseen, which has to do with the knowledge of Allaah
about these five matters. The matters of the unseen as far as the foetus
are concerned are: how long he will remain in his mother’s womb, his
life, his deeds, his provision, whether he is doomed (destined for Hell)
or blessed (destined for Paradise), and – before it is fully formed
– whether it will be male or female. But after it has been fully formed,
knowledge of whether it is male or female is no longer the matter of
the unseen, because once it has been fully formed it becomes the matter
of the visible world, but it remains within the three layers of darkness
which, if they were removed, it would be known what it is. It is not
far-fetched to think that among the things that Allaah has created are
powerful rays which can penetrate these layers of darkness so that it
may become clear whether the foetus is male or female. The aayah does
not clearly refer to knowledge of whether the foetus is male or female,
and the Sunnah does not refer to that either.
With regard to what the questioner refers to, that Ibn
Jareer quoted from Mujaahid that a man asked the Prophet
(peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) what his wife would give
birth to, and Allaah revealed this aayah, this narration is munqati’
(interrupted), because Mujaahid (may Allaah have mercy on him) was one
of the Taabi’een.
The tafseer of Qutaadah (may Allaah have mercy
on him) may be interpreted as meaning that Allaah Alone has knowledge
of that so long as it has not yet been fully formed. But once the foetus
is fully formed, then others may have knowledge of it. Ibn Katheer (may
Allaah have mercy on him) said in his tafseer of the aayah from Soorat
Luqmaan: “No one knows what Allaah wants to create in the wombs
apart from Him, but once He decrees that it should be male or female,
doomed or blessed, the angels who are appointed in charge of it know
that, and whoever else He wills among His creation.”
With regard to your question about what may make the
general meaning of this aayah (“what is in the wombs”) more specific,
we say that if the aayah was speaking about being male or female after
the foetus is fully formed, then that which would make it more specific
would be tangible facts. The scholars have mentioned the principles
of making the general meanings of the Qur’aan and Sunnah more specific,
which are a text, ijmaa’ (scholarly consensus), qiyaas
(analogy), tangible facts or reason. Their comments on this matter are
But since the aayah does not refer to after the foetus
is fully formed, but rather it refers to before that time, there is
nothing in it that would contradict the idea of knowing whether the
foetus is male or female.
Praise be to Allaah, there is not, and never will be,
anything in reality that contradicts the unambiguous statements of the
Qur’aan. The accusations made by the enemies of the Muslims against
the Qur’aan, that things happen which outwardly appear to contradict
the Qur’aan, arise from their misunderstanding of the Book of Allaah
which stems from their bad intentions. But the committed Muslims and
scholars have enough knowledge to discover the truth which will refute
the specious arguments of these people. Praise and blessings be to Allaah.
With regard to this matter, people may be one of two
extremes, or a middle group.
One extreme is to adhere to the apparent meaning of Qur’aanic
verses which are not unambiguous, and to reject any certain facts that
go against it. Such people either expose themselves to criticism, or
they expose the Qur’aan to criticism, because their view contradicts
the certain realities of everyday life.
The other extreme is to turn away from that which is
indicated by the Qur’aan and to adopt a purely materialistic approach.
Thus one becomes a heretic.
The middle path is to accept both the indications of
the Qur’aan and the facts of reality. These people know that both of
them are true, and that the unambiguous statements of the Qur’aan cannot
contradict something that is well known and visible. They combine acceptance
of the transmitted texts with reason, thus keeping their religious commitment
and their intellect safe and sound. Allaah guides those who believe
to the truth of that wherein they differ, and Allaah guides whom He
wills to a Straight Path (cf. al-Baqarah 2:213).
May Allaah help our believing brothers to achieve
that, and may He cause us to be guided and to guide others, and make
us righteous leaders. My strength is only in Allaah, in Him I put my
trust and to Him I turn in repentance.